Anne Gregory's journey and Women in PR interview
In this episode of Women in PR, I speak with Anne Gregory, Chair of Corporate Communication at the University of Huddersfield and former Chair of the Global Alliance for Public Relations and Communication Management, about the Global Capability Framework for the profession. We talk about the difference between competencies and capabilities, how the framework can be used by individuals, teams and organizations, what it takes to become a trusted advisor, and how the seven-continent research behind the framework was carried out.
Episode at a glance
Podcast: Women in PR with Ana Adi, Series 2, Episode 20
Guest: Anne Gregory, Chair of Corporate Communication, University of Huddersfield (at the time of recording)
Host: Prof. Dr. Ana Adi, Quadriga University of Applied Sciences, Berlin
First released: July 25, 2021 · Length: 58 minutes
Listen to the full episode above or on SoundCloud. Prefer to watch? The episode is also on YouTube, and you can find every episode on my YouTube channel in the Women in PR playlist.
Takeaways (AI-generated with Claude from the episode transcript)
- PR is a global profession, yet until the framework it had no international benchmark for capability
- Competency frameworks list skills and knowledge in detail and go out of date as soon as they're built
- A capability approach describes the profession at its best in a minimum number of statements
- Capabilities are context free: you should be as good as you can be where you actually work
- Teams can share capabilities, so no individual needs to excel in all of them
- What a practitioner focuses on is a negotiation with their employer and professional association, not a free-for-all
- Trusted advisors bring contextual and communicative intelligence, showing leaders how the world sees their organization
- To be heard by senior leaders, communicators must learn their language and attach themselves to their agenda
- Equipping others in the organization to communicate frees specialists for strategic counsel
- The framework was built from country studies on every inhabited continent and must keep being updated
Transcript
AI transcription disclosure: This transcript was produced automatically with AI speech-recognition software and then edited for readability with the help of an AI assistant (Claude): punctuation, speaker names and the removal of filler words and false starts. It has not been checked word for word against the recording and may contain errors. The audio is the authoritative version.
Ana Adi
This is Women in PR, a podcast about inspiring women that have embraced PR and made it shine, changing it for the better every day. It's about mentors, founders, researchers, role models and leaders. I am Ana Adi. Women in PR is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com.
We've spoken a lot in this series about internationalization and globalization and how they influence public relations. We spoke about culture and language, about work setups, collaboration and research, and we often found out about the career journeys and educational backgrounds of our guests. And in doing so, we ended up musing about the skills, knowledge and attributes one needs to practice PR, and about whether there's any agreement internationally about how to train and recruit for comms. Is there something that unites PR practice globally? And more importantly, is there something that the PR practice as a whole can identify as its ideal professional self?
Now, Anne Gregory will help us find some answers to these questions. She's currently Chair of Corporate Communication at the University of Huddersfield in the UK and has formerly chaired the Global Alliance for Public Relations and Communication Management. It is during her tenure there that she directed the seven-continent team in developing the Global Capability Framework for the profession, a framework that we want to talk about today. Now, among many things that Anne has written, there are more than 80 publications, and it's the CIPR's AI in PR Ethics Guide, AI as in artificial intelligence.
And it's so wonderful to have you here today. Welcome to the show.
Anne Gregory
Well, it's great to be with you. Thank you for inviting me here.
Ana Adi
So a couple of years ago, you have coordinated a project that ended up being called the Global Capability Framework for public relations. This is something that you've done on behalf of the Global Alliance, and you've worked with fellow researchers around the world, really. So tell me, what is the Global Alliance, to start with, and what is the Global Capability Framework all about?
Anne Gregory
Okay, so the Global Alliance is the international confederation of professional associations in public relations and communication management around the world. So the professional associations, such as the German institute, the Chartered Institute of Public Relations in the UK, the Public Relations Society of America, are all members of the Global Alliance. And they come together as a grouping because there are certain things that we need to do on behalf of the profession globally, and the Global Capability Framework is exactly one of those things.
And the sort of drivers behind it was a recognition that we are a global profession now. We've got consultancies that operate across the world, multinationals with offices around the world, and of course international trade, globalization, means that communication is not constrained within national boundaries, and it hasn't been for a while. And therefore it was really quite amazing that there was no international benchmark for capability in public relations and communication management across the world. The accountants have got this sorted out, nursing and engineers have got this sorted out, but we haven't.
And so the Global Alliance said, we need to think about this. We need to have really a common vision of what our profession is at its best, something that scopes the profession and something that gives us an understanding that whether you work in China or whether you work in Germany or the UK, there's a recognizable range of activities and imperatives for the profession that gives us a commonality of purpose and helps us to speak a common language about the profession. Those were the impetuses for generating this Global Capability Framework.
Ana Adi
So before you tell us a little bit about the capabilities and what they are, I'm very aware that there's a lot of confusion around terms. So I've heard talk about capabilities, we also speak about competencies, not to mention, I mean, in English you have competence and competencies, which for any non-native English speaker is a mouthful and a whole load of confusion. Can you clarify a little bit what's the difference between competence, competency and sort of capability, and what do they have to do with one another?
Anne Gregory
Right. Well, you're absolutely right, there is a lot of confusion around these terms, and to make it simple, I would say that there are two main approaches. So the competency approach looks at all those skills, knowledge, abilities, behaviors that comprise a profession. So it takes all the individual building blocks, if you like. So you need skills to be able to do media relations or to be able to write, and you build a picture of the profession right from the basics, and then you go on to knowledge and you go on to abilities, and you build this huge edifice which says, this is what describes the profession in terms of the skills, knowledge and proficiencies that you have to have.
And there are lots and lots of these competency frameworks, and in fact the Global Alliance did a piece of work to look at all the existing competency frameworks, and we did an aggregation of them, and we ended up with a document of over 30 pages, these huge lists of skills and knowledge. And this is a very unmanageable way to actually go about describing your profession, because you can imagine, it's out of date as soon as you build it.
So there's a different approach, and it's called the capability approach. And what the capability approach tries to do is to describe the profession in all its richness, its scope and its depth, in a minimum number of statements. And this is happening in other professions. So in engineering they do this now. I mentioned nursing; the nursing profession is moving towards this. And what happens with the capability approach is that it's about the aspirations. It's what the potential of the profession might be when you describe it at your best.
And the key thing about capability is that it's context free. So let me give you a quick example. So one of our competencies, sorry, how do you say that again? Capabilities. So let me give you an example. One of our capabilities is to communicate effectively across a full range of platforms and technologies. Now, depending on where you are around the world, there might be different platforms and technologies that are available to you. But what this statement says is that you need to be absolutely up to date in the context in which you operate. It doesn't say that you have to use Twitter or you have to be on Instagram or TikTok or whatever. It just says you have to be capable in modern platforms of communication.
So it's sort of context free, and it's also non-judgmental as well, in that it says you have to be the best that you can be within your context. Now, if you live in an African nation, maybe, where the infrastructure is not as well developed as in some other nations, or in Latin America, where it's very difficult to receive broadband, then your context might constrain you. So it says that you've got to be as good as you possibly can be in the context in which you operate, without setting an absolute standard.
And that's one of the problems with capability frameworks, is that they're often graded. So you have to do this at this level to be regarded as competent, in other words fully capable in the activity that you undertake. And it might be that you can't be at this level because the context in which you operate doesn't allow you to be; you don't have access to broadband. So this idea of having a context-free set of statements, which is the capability approach, means that it can be applicable wherever you are across the world.
Ana Adi
Right, because one of the initial criticisms of the competence framework and assessment that you've carried out for the Global Alliance was that it works for corporations and multinational organizations that had structures in place, most of the time hierarchical, but for anything that was outside of this growth structure, they didn't quite fit. That the framework in itself became quite narrow, right? So in this sense, if you were in an NGO or if you were in a startup, your role as a communicator didn't have either the bandwidth or the capacity, in a sense, to take it from junior to senior to manager to, I don't know, ruler of the world and the universe. So what you're saying is that the capability framework therefore looks at what the profession should look like and kind of mitigates for that, right? So it's your response to your previous research.
Anne Gregory
Absolutely right. And this is one of the challenges that we've got. You're right, we work in small organizations as professionals and large organizations. A director of communications for a huge telecom company in Germany will have a very different job from a small or medium-sized enterprise based in Germany. And therefore the ability of somebody to say, I excel in my competence, is very difficult if you're working in a small organization.
However, if you describe capability as, let's pick another capability, to facilitate relationships and build trust with internal and external stakeholders and communities, I can do that brilliantly in a small enterprise, and I can make a judgment about what that might be in discussion with the senior leaders of my organization. So it's again this ability to take it out of a context which we imagine, and the context is usually imagined by professional associations as being large organizations, as you quite rightly state, but actually locate this in the context that people are actually working. That is crucially important.
And that's what makes this capability approach so flexible and so right across the world, for whether you're working in the public sector, private sector, NGOs, whether you're working in Africa, Asia, Europe, Scandinavia. You can calibrate it, and there are no scores out of 10 for this. 10 out of 10 is dictated by the circumstances in which you operate.
Ana Adi
So, but still, I mean, one of the things that could be confusing stems exactly from the fact that this is non-contextual. Bear with me for a second. So most of the time, the job description for a communications position is written, ideally, by the HR department together with the comms team, ideally. And if you look, I'm giggling because one of our students is actually carrying out a piece of research right now, her master's thesis, looking into something like this. But if you're looking at how the job descriptions look like and look at the capabilities framework, none of these things are met. It's just such a world of difference between what organizations out there are thinking and asking communicators to do versus what, as a profession, we're saying that a communicator should do.
So what's your view on this? How do we bridge, how do we bring together these two worlds? What's a piece of advice to those who recruit, to say, well, look, pay attention to these things, and this is kind of what you should consider when you write those job adverts?
Anne Gregory
Yeah, yeah. And again, it's perfectly legitimate for an organization to say, this is the basic capability, but we want you to operate at this level. Absolutely right, I think. And it's absolutely right to combine both approaches. So you can say, we want you to be fully competent across a range of platforms and technologies in communication, and you need to be proficient in whatever social media is preferred by that organization. So it's not an either-or approach, I don't think here, Ana, because you might take something that's context free like this, but certainly in the context in which you operate, there might be certain requirements on you. So you can take these capabilities as broad headings, and then you can add whatever calibration is right for you within your situation.
And really interestingly, we're talking to you in Germany now, and I did some work with a huge German engineering company, with one of the teams who was actually based in Spain. And we went through these capabilities with the team as a whole, and there's a really interesting conversation that then happened about, well, look, we don't need to be fully competent and capable in all these things individually, but as a team we'll decide who is going to focus on what strengths. And therefore, looking on to succession planning, then they were wanting to use this capability framework to frame job descriptions and future adverts, and they wouldn't expect anybody to fulfill all these capabilities at all. They were going to choose some, because the team as a whole would fulfill the full complement of these capabilities. And they were also, under these job descriptions, going to say, and you must be proficient in certain skills and knowledge as well. And that's a great use of this.
I would not expect anybody to score, not that there are scores, but to be fully proficient in all these capabilities, because, again, I use that word context, your context will determine what's required of you. And let me give you a personal example here. I used to work for a bank as a practitioner, and our bank had a banking organization that represented us, the banking sector, to government. So I didn't do any lobbying when I was a practicing professional, but I would say that in other areas I was highly skilled, not in lobbying. And that's the reality of the lived lives of practitioners.
And that's why this capability framework, I think, is applicable, because you can be massively capable in one area and not capable in another, and you know what, it doesn't matter, because your circumstances will dictate what capabilities you need to focus on. And as you change your jobs, those emphases will change as well. So this again is the beauty of having something as flexible as this.
Ana Adi
So you're saying capabilities therefore are for the team or the department as a whole, and we still need to go back to the GBOK, right, the Global Alliance Body of Knowledge project, that can give you an idea of how you fill in those gaps, and at the individual level.
Anne Gregory
It operates at a number of levels. It operates for individuals. And I don't want to give the wrong impression here, because you could say, well, Anne, you're advocating a free-for-all. You choose what you are capable at, and that's supposed to be okay with everybody. Well, of course not. There has to be a negotiation here. There has to be a negotiation with my employer about what they regard as the requirements for capability. There has to be a negotiation with my professional association. If I'm going to be a member of a professional association, they will have some judgment on the basics that are required for you to be called competent or capable, going back to the confusions in languages.
This is not me just choosing and saying, that's okay for me, that's where I'm going to stick. This is something that has to be agreed with the organization that you work with and with others. And this is a global capability framework, and therefore, even beyond your national boundaries, to be fully capable, then there's these 11 capabilities that you would want to look at and say, well, is this a capability that applies to me when I'm working in the global context? Or am I working with other people who are also capable in certain areas, and they're more capable than me, so I will focus on these areas? So this is quite a nuanced piece of work here, and I wouldn't want this to be regarded as a trivial piece of work, because it's not, and it's not a free-for-all.
So it applies to the individual. And the way that I'm seeing this being used at the moment is we have a little software tool that allows you to make a judgment about where you think your capabilities are on a sliding scale, so no numbers on this, but are you more or less capable in these 11 capabilities? And I've seen this used where an individual will do that and their manager will do this about them. And what it does is it opens up a conversation then, Ana. So I think I'm capable in this area, my manager doesn't, so that then is a development opportunity for me.
And I will probably be a member of a team, so my manager then takes an overview perspective of the whole team and says, I need a balanced team, so I do require Anne to work in certain areas. This is what she's really good at, and okay, she may need to develop in this capability, but not now, maybe in three years' time, when, as part of her overall career trajectory, she will need to build up capability in this area to gain promotion. So there can be a really interesting conversation between individuals and their manager.
And then I mentioned this huge engineering company based in Germany, and the conversation there was about the capability of the whole team. And this was really interesting, because it was about the whole team taking responsibility for their work within the organization, and the specialisms that some of them might have, whether they needed generalists or whether they needed hyper-specialists in certain areas. And they decided that they needed both. They needed a flexible team, and therefore they wanted some rounded practitioners who were essentially capable in everything, so they could support their team members, and then others who were specializing in particular capabilities.
So for example, if somebody wanted to specialize in being a trusted advisor to senior managers, there's certain skills and knowledge that you need to develop to take on that role. Whereas if somebody wanted to take a much more hands-on approach and be focused on actual communication activities in channels, and that's where they wanted to focus their work, then there will be skills and knowledge that they need to develop over time. So taking this holistic perspective is really important, both for the individual, for teams, for the organization.
Ana Adi
Now, I have a slew of questions coming from here, because what if you don't have a team? What if you work in such a small organization, or you're right at the beginning, that there is no such team, but comms is still essential? How are you going to go about it? And you did mention the trusted advisor, so I'd like us to go back to it, because you said that if you want to focus on being a trusted advisor, there's something… But back to what if there's no team: how then do you go about comms and, well, arguably, the capabilities framework within your organization?
Anne Gregory
Yeah, so that's a really great question. So as I mentioned earlier, this capability framework scopes the whole of the profession, and if you're a single practitioner, whether you work for an organization or if you're a freelancer, it's unlikely that you're going to excel in all these. So that's where the choices between you and the organization that you work for come into play. So what's important, and you will decide in discussion with them. Having something external like this as a basis to have that discussion, that's really important as well.
And one of the uses that we find for this capability framework is that people have been using it to go to their managers and say, look, this is the huge scope of our role. Now, if you're a big team, you might be able to take responsibility for all these areas. If you're a single practitioner, it's likely that you will have to focus on a small number of these and be really good at them. And depending on how big the organization is, or what its particular communication requirements are, you can have that as a discussion in the full knowledge that you're not fulfilling all the activities and roles that this capability framework would suggest that we would have responsibility for.
So that comes down to organizational and individual choices, and that's why I say it's not a free-for-all, really. This is a negotiation, but you do it in full knowledge that you're probably not fulfilling the whole of the potential for the public relations and communication management function within the organization. And it's a bit like in medicine: consultants specialize, but they specialize knowing that there are a whole range of medical areas that they're not going to undertake, because they choose their specialization. And that's perfectly legitimate, and that will be based both on their individual preferences, you know, I want to be an orthopedic surgeon, and the demand for orthopedic surgeons in the country or in a particular hospital.
So it's exactly the same discussion that you might have, and I think it's important that we understand that it's then a discussion based on knowledge, rather than a manager saying, well, I think all public relations should be responsible for is media relations, off you go. Well, here's an external document that says no, it's about much more than that. Now, what's important for us…
Ana Adi
Well, that's certainly great to hear, and, you know, that the Global Capabilities Framework is also meant as a discussion starter and demystifier, in the sense of what the profession should be about. Now, before we go to the process and how you got here, because it's quite an extensive two years' research, international team and whatnot, let's answer that question about how do you get to be a trusted advisor.
In my other podcast interviews, many of our previous guests have referred increasingly to this idea that comms practitioners should be a trusted advisor. What does that mean? How do you get there? Because, you know, trust is not something that you buy on the market. It's not readily available. You don't build it either, in the sense that, I mean, I think you should be trustworthy, and others decide whether they trust you or not. And particularly in organizations, you know, the bigger they are, the more power comes into… whether it's interpersonal relationships, all sorts of things come into the way of the comms person being the trusted advisor. But you said there is something that communicators who have this as a career desire can focus on and learn. So what is it that we can do to get to be trusted advisors?
Anne Gregory
I think we could do a whole program on this one, but very briefly, I think that you are absolutely right. A trusted advisor is, first of all, somebody who is trustworthy, and a trusted advisor is somebody who is prepared to tell the truth, speak truth to power, is the saying in English, and somebody who is able to understand what's going on in the mind of the person that they are advising. And I think this is a crucial element here. So a trusted advisor is not necessarily somebody who tells a senior manager what to do all the time, and is able to get alongside them and do a number of things.
And let me just introduce one or two things that I think a trusted advisor as a communication specialist might offer somebody. So a senior manager, a chief executive, whether it be for a small or for a big company, is surrounded by people who have a particular perspective on the world, and often that is dictated by the specialism that they have. So often a trusted advisor to a CEO would be the director of finance, and they see the world through a resource lens. It's about money, it's about how you structure the organization, it's about the bottom line. The operations director will see the world through an operations lens: so are we effective, are we efficient in the processes that we have?
Now, a communication advisor, I believe, has a very different perspective. First of all, they don't have the same functional lens, so they come at this from a neutral stance. And the communication stance really is very similar to the chief executive's. A chief executive has to see the world and make decisions in the round. So taking all that advice from the several people who will advise them, they then have to synthesize the perspective of the finance director, the operations director, the HR director, et cetera, et cetera, and come to a round decision.
Now, the communication person does that all the time. They have what I call contextual intelligence. So this is an understanding of what is going on in the round, and particularly an external perspective. So organizations exist when they are given permission to exist by society and by the stakeholders that engage with them. So what is their perspective? What are their expectations? And because the comms person is in intimate contact with those constituencies who give the organization their license to operate, they're able to give the CEO that external perspective, to see the organization as others see it, and to see it in the context of the web of complexity in which it operates, where society's views on things are constantly shifting and where the pressures on organizations from outside are being nuanced day on day. And we only have to think about the political context in which we operate to know how true that is.
And somebody who is able to sit alongside the chief executive and say, this is how the world sees us, this is how the world sees our future, this is how the world sees how we should respond in these situations, is an incredibly important asset. Because what a chief executive wants is for their organization to be sustainable, and by that I don't just mean environmentally sustainable, I mean to have long life. And to have long life, you have to secure the support of those individuals and groups on whom you are dependent, and that might be employees. Increasingly it's employees. And who's best connected to employees and can advise the chief executive about what employee morale is like and what their expectations of the organization are? The communication person, who is well connected with those groups and individuals, and important constituencies outside the organization who have expectations of the organization.
The communication person who can advise the chief executive about what's going on outside and bring that intelligence in, and who can advise the chief executive about the decisions that he or she will make and how they will be accepted by those important constituencies that I've mentioned, it's the communication person. And I can't think of a more important role, particularly in the current environment that we live in, that trusted advisor perspective given by a communications person.
And a communication person, apart from having that sort of contextual intelligence, has communicative intelligence as well, which means that it's not just the decisions that you make, it's how you communicate them that is crucially important. And we know about the importance of empathy, we know about the importance of resonance with those constituencies on whom you are dependent. Who is going to advise you on that? It's not going to be the accountant, it's not going to be the operations person, it's the communication person who understands those sorts of things. So without going into the detail of communication advice, those perspectives, I think, are crucially important for senior managers, whether they're in small organizations or big organizations, and that only the communication person can give.
Ana Adi
So, but you see, as you were giving these examples, in the back of my mind there was one commentary going on, and that is that if the comms person is being accepted… And again, from various interviews, and there's also quite some literature coming up right now reconsidering the role of the communications function and the role of the communicator in an organization, there seems to be an increasing requirement coming both from academics and professionals alike that comms shouldn't stay within the remit of the comms department alone, but rather that knowledge, understanding and training, to a fair degree, into good, effective, impactful communications should go beyond the comms function.
So going back to maybe your German example, you know, this German company with its office in Spain, that their CEOs and their engineers should get courses in what is effective comms, and sort of make the difference between psychology, interpersonal communication, mass communication, persuasive communication, so that we can kind of start to appreciate where the communicator can help, rather than just think that they will solve all the problems. And once that is being understood and internalized, then comms has an easier job, obviously, becoming a trusted advisor.
Now, that kind of has to do a little bit with the future of the profession and how do we get to fulfilling the capability framework's mandate, in a sense, right? Because the capabilities framework includes communication capabilities, which are about aligning strategies with organizational purpose and values, identifying communication problems proactively, so there's research there, in a sense, included, evaluation as well. And then we have organizational and professional capabilities. And if we go to these professional capabilities, where the valued counsel and trusted advisor fits in, arguably, as a professional, you can't fulfill that successfully unless others let you do it.
Anne Gregory
Yeah.
Ana Adi
So where do we go from here? How do we make comms… are we going back to the beginning? How do we make comms as a profession legit in the eyes of the others? Because for us, obviously, we're here, we talk about it, we do research, so for us it's legit. How do we make it legit and credible and legitimate and worthy for others?
Anne Gregory
Yeah, I think there's a huge lot of stuff to unpack in what you've just said there, Ana.
Ana Adi
I don't make it easy on you.
Anne Gregory
We should talk all day. Just going back to a trusted advisor role: we find that the best trusted advisors very rarely talk about communication tactics. They talk about securing the legitimacy of the organization, they talk about protecting the reputation of the organization because senior people are about to make decisions that are not going to be supported. So that's not all that much to do with communication per se, although the communication professional will then have to go out and communicate those decisions very often, and that's a whole other job.
But one of the problems, and we know that it's been a problem for generations now, is that the communications profession as a whole has remained very siloed into doing communications. Most people within our profession do not have MBAs. They're not taught in business schools, and that's where most senior managers have actually spent their educational lives. So we have to think in terms of how do chief executives and senior people think. So we have to learn their language, we have to learn the sort of sequence of decision-making steps that they go through, we have to learn what's important to them. And the bottom line for us is, we have to attach ourselves to their agenda.
For years now I've had people asking me, communication professionals, but why… I talk to them about communication and the importance of communications, and they don't accept me. And so, well, let's just flip this round. How much of their agenda do you understand? How many of their priorities do you know about? Do you understand the pressures that these people are under? Do you understand that they've got a board above them who are asking questions in these areas? And how does communication actually contribute and solve some of the pressure issues that those senior people are struggling under? And how do you actually address those issues that they think are important, rather than expecting them to think about communication? Because otherwise we're just adding to their to-do list.
And it's really an interesting exercise to actually think about senior people in the organization and say, well, what is it that preoccupies them? What keeps them awake at night? What are the issues that they are struggling with, and how can communication help with them? And it's probably not to trivialize this by writing a press release. This is about engaging with them on the key issues that face the future of the organization, and what intelligence can we bring in that helps them with those issues. And that's the heart of the trusted advisor for me. It's not going to them with a comms solution necessarily, it's about going through with them and working alongside them.
This is a trusted advisor role, not a trusted decision-maker role, where you actually understand and unpack for them what some of the tangled issues are, bring in that intelligence that I talked about, their knowledge of the wider world, knowledge of the internal organization, because you are connected, to helping them work through some of those issues. And that for me is the essence of the trusted advisor role.
And a route to doing that is often because you demonstrate competence, competence in what you're doing. So as a junior practitioner, or maybe in a smaller organization, you're going to be red hot at doing the communication stuff, and that's almost your entry ticket. Just again to take a parallel: as a junior accountant, you will go in and you'll be an auditor, you'll be a junior auditor, and you add up the columns. I've sat on a number of boards, and the finance director never talked about adding up the columns. So if we want to be a trusted advisor, we've got to stop talking about the equivalent of adding up the columns. What that finance director says is, well, these are the pressures, these are financial pressures and imperatives that we need to consider as a board. These are the areas where we can, you know, secure, if you like, sources of finance. These are threats to our sources of finance. This is where the business is hemorrhaging. And it was never columns.
So I think that the shift in the profession, therefore, is exactly what you say, and we're our own worst enemy, I think, because we hang on to the columns. We say, no, you can't do communication activities, because it's so important that only we can do it. Well, again, we have to get out of that mentality. There used to be a time, you know, as a senior manager in the university myself, and I have been a very senior manager, less senior now because of my choice, but there used to be a time, we were talking about HR before, when HR sat in all the interviews, they wrote all the job descriptions and they ran the process of recruitment. They don't do that now. They don't do disciplining of staff. We might go to them for advice about the law, HR law, but managers take responsibility for HR. Same with budgeting. You know, there used to be an accountant sat next to me when I put budgets together for my department. That doesn't happen now. You are responsible for budgets.
And what you've said about equipping individuals within the organization to have competence in communication is absolutely right. And what's the result of that? Two things. First of all, it releases so much time, so that practitioners who are specialists in communication can do these roles, like being a trusted counsel and thinking about the things that are going to be impacting on the organization, because they have time to do that, instead of rushing around doing communication stuff. But it also means that communication then can be embedded within the organization, and you've got a whole set of individuals and departments who can offer you resource and intelligence.
And I don't know why we haven't gone down this route years ago, but as a profession we've been so insecure that unless we're doing the communication minutiae, we feel that we're not going to be respected. We need to get rid of that. Of course we need to monitor it, and of course we need to set standards for it, and of course we need to be available when people have got difficult communication problems. But bring it on, as far as I'm concerned. Let's get people properly equipped, and then, just like in loads of other functions, we've got a range of people who are competent at doing communication. Wouldn't that solve a lot of our problems? Because many of our problems are generated by other people's communication mistakes.
Ana Adi
Well, that's a lot that we… We're slowly coming to an end of our conversation today, the official conversation. Ours, I'm sure, is going to continue way more beyond the official time, and I hope everybody else will check out the Global Alliance, the GBOK and the capability framework and have a think of that.
But tell me a little bit, because we've been dancing around this idea since the beginning: how is this research set up? You were at the University of Huddersfield at the time. It took about two years, if I remember right. How do you come up with a capabilities framework that speaks to the world? How did you go about setting the research up, selecting your research partners, in a way that gave you, as a coordinator of the team, and therefore everybody else who's reading the results of the project, the confidence that this is something that they can consider and potentially embrace?
Anne Gregory
Yes, so it was a long project and a complex project, and I would just like to give a shout-out to my colleague, Dr. Johanna Fawkes, who was the principal investigator on the project. I was the director of the project, but Johanna worked full time on this project and was absolutely brilliant.
So the way that we approached it was, first of all, we did some work on what sort of framework we should put together, and we decided on the capability approach. So this is an approach that comes from development economics, actually. [inaudible] is the big academic on this, clearly from Asian origin, which is interesting in itself, because a lot of the competency frameworks come from the West. So this capability framework was generated in a non-Western country. There's sort of philosophy behind it, and the work of Sen and Martha Nussbaum in development economics has been adopted by a lot of forward-thinking professions now, as saying, well, look, we need something that's going to be applicable across the world. And the idea is that capability looks at potential and what a profession can be at its best.
So what we did was to look around the world and say, well, look, one of the issues around GBOK… And again, my colleague Jean Valin, who led that work, did an absolutely fantastic job of bringing together all those knowledge, skills, attributes and behavior frameworks, but a lot of them originate in the West, and I mentioned the issues of difficulty of updating them. So what we wanted to do was to try and get something that was truly global in perspective.
So we decided that we would work with academics based in six continents around the world, representing every major bloc. So in Latin America, my current colleague, Professor Gabriel Sadi, led the research from Argentina. In Asia, my colleague Professor Gregor Halff, who's based in Singapore but worked all around Asia, led the work there. We had representatives from Australia, Spain in Europe, because Europe is not all one bloc, as we know, so southern Europe, ourselves, in northern Europe Scandinavia, United States, Canada, so every continent, every inhabited continent represented, and Africa as well, of course.
And what our colleagues did was they worked together with the professional associations and with other practitioner groups, employers for example, and academics, on designing for their country a country framework. The advantage of the particular group of individuals that we got together was that all of them have got experience of working in, and deep knowledge of, other countries. So for example, our researcher in the USA was Professor Katerina Tsetsura, who's based at the University of Oklahoma. You can probably tell from her name that she doesn't come from America; she's actually Russian, and she has deep knowledge of communication in Russia and Eastern Europe, which was invaluable. Australia, Dr. Marianne Sison, who is based at RMIT, is a Filipino by birth, and she knows Southeast Asia incredibly well. So all the researchers had experience of practice and academic thinking around the world.
So what we did was we consulted experts within each country that these academics were located in, and we did a survey of practitioners, we ran surveys with academics and employers, we ran focus groups, and that's why it took two years, where we gained a deep understanding of the capabilities within each country. Then we all gathered together as a research group in London, and we spent two days going through the country frameworks, actually coming to conclusions about what the global community would accept as being relevant to them. That meant, for example, that some of the UK capabilities that we came across were not actually present in the Global Capability Framework, because around the world the practice is different. So this wasn't just an aggregation of the country capability studies. We actually deconstructed them thoroughly, and we drew together these 11 capabilities on a common understanding of what would be applicable around the world.
And we tested that framework then in different countries and with the Global Alliance itself, and the board of the Global Alliance, as I mentioned, has representatives of associations from around the world on it. So this was a really rigorous process, and we came up with the 11 capabilities which are now represented in the framework. And they're grouped, as you said, into three categories: those that are specific to communication; we thought about the organizational contribution; and then we thought about professional capabilities. And these are capabilities that would be acceptable to most professions. I can think, in medicine and accounting, for example, being a trusted advisor would be a capability that they would own. Working within an ethical framework would be something they would accept. And developing themselves and others, being constantly up to date, is a mark of being a professional.
So that's how the process took place. It was tested and monitored, it's been peer reviewed through conferences and papers, so we know that it was a rigorous process. And the fact that it's been adopted around the world, and other countries are actually undertaking their own studies based on our research methodology, indicates that it has a rigor about it and a level of acceptability which we're proud of, and we feel is a service to the global community.
Ana Adi
So what's next? The capability framework is out, research continues. What do you think should be next, and what is next for you in terms of research?
Anne Gregory
So this is not something that should be static, as you say. It came out in mid-2018, and this is something that should be constantly updated. Because it doesn't have all these huge number of building blocks of skills and knowledge, it can be updated. And at the moment we've got some more country studies happening. So for example, in Indonesia there's a study happening, Turkey, Malaysia, Qatar, UAE, so a number of countries. In Latin America, Ecuador and Peru are doing studies. So around the world we've got more studies happening, and so we want to refresh the capability framework to make sure that it is reflective of both broad practice across the world and current practice.
The actual headings, Ana, are relatively timeless. So, you know, to communicate effectively across a full range of platforms and technologies, I can't imagine that that will change massively. But it may be that some of the sub-capabilities, and each capability has three or four sub-capabilities, require additional nuance. And the fact that we've got new things happening in the profession, as you say, more and more emphasis on this trusted counselor role, it may be that we would want to flesh this out more extensively and give a rounder picture of what that might mean through the sub-capabilities.
So what's next is constant modulation, moderation, nuance of the framework, throwing it out all together if that's appropriate, or that would surprise me. But this is something that has to remain live, has to be dynamic, and has to represent the potential of the profession as it moves forward and develops.
Ana Adi
So, like all research in our time, the end is not here.
Anne Gregory
No, just the start place.
Ana Adi
Exactly. Well, and thank you so very much. We've covered quite a lot of ground in this hour. I just go back to saying what you've said at the beginning of our conversation, and that is that the capabilities framework is there to help everybody else think of the profession, of how it would be at its best. And so this is what we're operating with, with a minimum of statements of desirable traits of the profession. So, as I said, with that in mind, do check all the materials out there. It's fascinating and valuable reading. And thank you very, very much, and I'm sure that you and I will definitely hear of each other soon enough.
Anne Gregory
Thank you so much for having me today, I really appreciate it. And thank you to everybody who's listening to the podcast. Please go and look at the framework and give us your feedback, because this is a living thing.
Ana Adi
Now remember: 11 capabilities towards an understanding of PR applicable around the world. If you haven't heard of the Global Alliance Capability Framework and all the research underpinning it, do check it out now. It's essential reading.
Next week is our final stop in the series, and we return to Germany to chat with Katja Bott from Mercedes-Benz Cars and Vans Global Communications, to speak about digital car reveals and PR's evolving to an integrated and integrative function. See you next week.
Women in PR is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com. To learn more about the show and my guests, do check out the show notes. If you liked the show, do share it. If you have comments and suggestions, find me on Twitter or LinkedIn. I am Ana Adi. Thank you for listening.
Women in PR with Ana Adi is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com.