Lindsay Uitenbogaard's journey and Women in PR interview
In this episode of Women in PR, I speak with Lindsay Uittenbogaard, who is behind Mirror Mirror, an alignment diagnostic tool and process for teams. Lindsay tells me how a car-sharing business she started in the UK in the early 1990s brought her into public relations, and why she sees employee communication as sharing meaning rather than getting people to do or think something. We talk about the research behind alignment, the stories people make up when clarity is missing, why constructive challenge is part of the process, and what team leads and communicators can do as remote and hybrid work make misalignment harder to raise.
Episode at a glance
Podcast: Women in PR with Ana Adi, Series 2, Episode 17
Guest: Lindsay Uittenbogaard, Director, Mirror Mirror (at the time of recording)
Host: Prof. Dr. Ana Adi, Quadriga University of Applied Sciences, Berlin
First released: June 28, 2021 · Length: 35 minutes
Listen to the full episode above or on SoundCloud. Prefer to watch? The episode is also on YouTube, and you can find every episode on my YouTube channel in the Women in PR playlist.
Takeaways (AI-generated with Claude from the episode transcript)
- Launching an unfamiliar car-sharing business out of university made public relations a necessity for Lindsay
- Employee communication is not about getting people to do or think something but about sharing meaning
- People need to socialize new thinking with others before they can internalize it and act on it
- In large organizations, the gap between strategic messaging and effective action fills with differing interpretations
- When clarity is missing, people make up stories to explain what is happening and act on them
- Misalignment always sits between people, and comparing everyone's views surfaces it without blame or finger-pointing
- Alignment is about constructive challenge and learning from each other, not about everyone holding the same opinion
- Remote work makes people more wary of raising concerns, which makes alignment work even more important
- Agile practices like daily huddles, after action reviews and structured feedback improve everyday conversations
- Good team leadership comes down to being organized and being human
Transcript
AI transcription disclosure: This transcript was produced automatically with AI speech-recognition software and then edited for readability with the help of an AI assistant (Claude): punctuation, speaker names and the removal of filler words and false starts. It has not been checked word for word against the recording and may contain errors. The audio is the authoritative version.
Ana Adi
This is Women in PR, a podcast about inspiring women that have embraced PR and made it shine, changing it for the better every day. It's about mentors, founders, researchers, role models and leaders. I am Ana Adi. Women in PR is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com.
Picture this: you are part of a team. You work remotely. Your work is good, so is that of your colleagues, but something isn't quite right. And you don't want any trouble, but it just doesn't feel like you and your colleagues are working towards the same goal. Is there a way to help you and your team work better together? Lindsay Uittenbogaard, today's guest, thinks so. She's behind Mirror Mirror, an alignment diagnostic tool and process that can help any type of team and inspire communicators.
Now, Lindsay has spent 15 years in employee communication leadership roles with multinational organizations in the energy, IT and telecommunication industries, based in the Netherlands, after having started as an entrepreneur in the UK. And now she's back at it, this time in the Netherlands, putting all her experience and research to a very good use.
Hello Lindsay, and welcome to the show.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Hi there, Ana. Thanks for having me on.
Ana Adi
Well, Lindsay, we often talk about professionals that inspire us and are inspiring, but we always start here on Women in PR with a question, and that is: how did you end up in comms, in public relations?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Yeah, so I'm gonna wind back a bit in time for this one, because when I first left university, I started up a small business. And the small business was an idea that nobody had heard of and knew about, and out of necessity I had to get into public relations. So it was all about generating awareness and building profile and credibility through articles, newspaper articles, TV interviews and whatever else would help build that awareness.
As time went on, I ended up working with a communications consultancy. I moved into employee communications, and it was really a kind of complete leap, if you like, from the micro small business world to the macro consulting world, where I broadened into employee comms. And that's where I've stayed, actually. So that's the kind of overview.
Ana Adi
Do you see them related, employee comms and PR? I mean, you've described it a little bit as being media relations and external comms. Do they have anything to do with one another?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Yeah, I mean, the common thread is about stakeholder relations. But I think the reason why people sometimes refer to employee communications outside of the PR space is because, in terms of public relations, media relations, you're often trying to get an audience to do or think something for your own objective. Whereas the contract that people have with employees is quite different, because there's a reciprocal relationship there, and often the environments are much more complex.
And so the stakeholder relations, if you like, to employees is, in my view, definitely not about getting them to do or think something. It's about sharing meaning. And particularly in today's world, where employees are more often more empowered to bring forward insights from their view of the world and their view of how the customer or the company is needing to do things differently, this reciprocation, this sort of sharing of meaning, is more like a dialogue communication process, if you like, where it's not about one party just getting somebody else to do something, but it's about people creating a shared reality together.
So they can be under the same umbrella, it's fine, but I think that there's a fundamental difference with employee communications to other, more traditional kind of stakeholder relations.
Ana Adi
Right. Now, going back to where you started, this idea that people had never heard of has materialized, but unfortunately not with you. Is that right?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
So I started a car-sharing agency inspired by the German Mitfahrzentrale, which was about matching passengers and drivers going the same way to share costs and to reduce their impact on the environment. And I did that in the UK for students and backpackers going from city to city. And we got a lot of, yeah, PR, a lot of sponsorship, and built up a membership of about 17,000 people. And that took about four years, and it was an incredible learning curve. And I had, you know, tons of energy and absolutely nothing to lose, and, you know, sort of threw myself into it.
But four years later, found that actually the critical mass that we needed for people to be matched up on the same day, to the same place, at the same time, just wasn't there, and the appetite wasn't really there either. And that's at a time when the internet, you know, wasn't really mainstream, and we were starting to use fax machines. It's unbelievable to think about the way it was back then. And of course car sharing today is huge, with big organizations, but they're running a different business model, to be honest. It is a different way forward. But yeah, that's what I was doing back then.
Ana Adi
So you've seen the future coming, but you were not patient enough to see it happening.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Well, I don't know if I would have had the technical vision that the current car share agency leaders have, and I don't know if I would have had this capability, or the ability to get the finance that would have been raised. So I was trying to do it my way. So ideologically, I think I had an idea that people should be sharing resources, particularly cars, but it's a kind of different model and a whole different approach. I don't see that I could have been that person in that driving seat there. So I don't kind of kick myself and say, you know, I should have held in there for another 15 years before it took off, because I was running my company, Freewheelers, in 1992 to '96.
Ana Adi
Wow.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
But it was an experience of which I'm using the learnings from today.
Ana Adi
Yeah, well, you did mention, I just… right, sending faxes to get people connected. I just haven't realized 1992 is so far away from us.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Yeah.
Ana Adi
But after Freewheelers, you've moved on a little bit into the corporate world, before you're now into your position of running again your own company. And it makes me wonder if coming up with running your own company comes out of learnings that happened throughout your career as a communicator, or out of frustration.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Well, I think it's both. And I mean, I've come to realize that, you know, there's only so far you can go if you're trying to be a square peg in a round hole, as they say. And I always felt, as soon as I got to be a consultant and then a member of staff in a large global organization, and I worked for three of them in the end, for 15 years, it was lovely kind of having the luxury that you have then. You know, somebody will just come along and fix your IT issues, well, hopefully. And, you know, you can network inside organizations and develop fantastic relationships and, you know, suggest ideas at least.
But ultimately, if you're an entrepreneur, which I realize I am, to be honest, quite significantly, it ends up being more frustrating, because you just cannot apply yourself in the way that you'd like to. So it's partly frustration, but it's partly because of something else I want to do that's more based on motivation. So there's positive and negative angles at the same time, the flip side of the same coin, if you like, to wanting to do something.
Ana Adi
Well, you often speak about employee communications, and you've said it just earlier, that it's not about getting employees to do things, but rather, you know, understanding and kind of working together. And a lot of the stuff that you do right now goes around alignment. Now, I know that you've done a lot of research on this, on the concept of alignment and how it works. Can you walk me through what you found out, and why is it that you think it's so important for teams of any kind, not only those who are in communication teams, to consider this concept?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Right, so I mean, the old-fashioned view of alignment is that an individual's goals will match up to the team goals and the company goals, and they'll be written down and everybody will understand them and everybody will be aligned. But I think the really fascinating piece comes in when you look at, for example, social constructionism from the 1970s, which basically says that people need to socialize their thinking in order to put them into context and to bed them down and internalize them and be able to act on them. So you can't just kind of send somebody a message of something that's quite different from the way that they were currently perceiving something, and expect them to just flip over into a different kind of reality without wanting to socialize it, make sense of it with other people.
And I think that really hit home when I went from this micro to this macro business world that I mentioned. In the micro business world, it still takes a lot of effort, just with a team in an organization of, say, 10 people, to really understand who's doing what, why are they doing it, how did it go, what are we doing differently. I mean, that whole piece on reflecting and planning and coordinating between people, it still takes a bit of effort, you know, but you can kind of get your head around it with 10 people, especially when you're working in the same place.
Now, when I went to work then in a blue-chip company, which was a hundred thousand people, that clarity and that sense of things just was not there. Because it's like, well, what's that team doing? And, you know, how would they possibly know this if they weren't in this meeting? And, well, if they're flying over there, then they won't be able to tell us what they thought about this. And, you know, just the entire kind of complexity and ambiguity that I felt so difficult to deal with. And in the role of communicator in that organization, I felt it was my responsibility to do something about it.
I really started to look at, well, what's the difference between strategic messaging and effective action? So when leaders kind of send out some communications, as typically happens in corporate communication departments, where they are sending a strategic message and expecting people to translate that with line managers into their own kind of team reality, and then that leads to some kind of coordinated, effective action that will implement that strategy, there's this huge space there between transmission of message and effective action that is just this kind of gap, where people are just hoping it will all come together with the line manager and the team. And in large organizations, that gap can be extremely foggy, full of people's different interpretations of the world.
And that's when you get into more kind of research about assumptions that people reach. You know, neuroscience talks about… and Carol Dweck is a really interesting researcher, a pioneer of this field, who talks about the fact that when our brains pick up on something that's changed, a message or a signal, or we experience something, we have to actually find an explanation that puts our mind to rest. Otherwise our minds are constantly distracted by: how come that doesn't make sense? How come that doesn't make sense? Almost as if we're kind of robots. And so without an explanation, consciously or unconsciously, we actually create assumptions and make up a story, if you like, to use as a placeholder until, if ever, we get the clarity that we need in order to know that what we're doing makes sense.
And there's some really interesting kind of follow-up research from that, from Bush and Kenwood, about conflicts in the workplace. And they're showing that, you know, 80 percent of conflicts at work occur because of stories people made up about what's happening and why, and use as the basis of actions. So if you like, if you see an organization full of people who are trying to socialize what's changing constantly, and trying to plug it into their own team reality, and having to make assumptions because the clarity isn't always there, and then using those assumptions, then the gap between intention and implementation gets bigger and bigger. And this is where some really big problems come in, and I think it's a communication challenge. So that's just some of the research work that we look at and what we base our alignment methodology on in order to fill that gap.
Ana Adi
Now, one of the things you're saying here is that people make up stories to kind of make sense of what happens to them at work. Now, making up stories doesn't necessarily have to be a storytelling or creative process, but rather it's filling in the gap, trying to come up with a reasonable explanation of why some things might happen. But that also kind of means that there's a way out of this. So how can we avoid such things, so that our teams are working smoothly?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Right, so that's a big question. And the quick answer is that the main problem about, let's call it misalignment, this gap between intention and implementation, or alignment: you can boil misalignment down to very concrete things, like, for example, cognitive misalignment, when people perceive the purpose of their team differently, for example. Or it could be behavioral alignment, when people have different ideas about how they're supposed to support each other within a team and collaborate to deliver.
And the big problem with misalignment is that it's always between people. So you cannot say to one person, what is misaligned in the team? Because they don't know what everybody else is thinking or how everybody else perceives things, so they're unable to speak on behalf of the team about where the problems are.
So the alignment solution that we are looking at, and I don't want to really use the word solution, but it's an approach that has a lot of valuable results, is where you collect views in a standard way about how people perceive their whole work reality. So that's about what's happening in the context, what's the strategy, the purpose, what's going on in the context. And also when you collect their views on how the team dynamics are at play in the areas of alignment and team learning, for example on psychological safety or task cohesion. And you collect data from people about how they perceive their world at work, and you compare the answers to show where the common ground and differences are, to identify exactly what is misaligned. So that's the main problem: it's actually identifying and measuring misalignment. So that's what Mirror Mirror does, that's what we do, and what I would say is a communication process.
Once you've done that, people know then where to specifically have conversations, without having to finger-point or blame people or bring up issues in an emotional way. It's simply: well, these are the views on how we see our team purpose, here's where we differ, and therefore let's have a conversation about, well, coming to common ground on what the team purpose is today and what it means for us going forward. And then on the behavioral side, it would be: well, here are the areas that we are misaligned on. Say, for example, perhaps you ask people if they've got freedom to raise issues and questions, and if there's a lot of discrepancy, or if there's a lot of difference between how people see the rating to that answer, then you would be able to talk about, okay, is that something we need to do better, and if so, how would we change that rating? So it really starts to bring it down to a very concrete, tangible way of identifying and closing the gaps.
Ana Adi
So, but what you describe here, to me, sounds like a very adult, very job-focused, here's-what-we've-got-to-do kind of thing. And it makes me wonder, I mean, this sounds wonderful, as in, here's how we might be conflict-free at work. But even discussing, you know, with a group within a team, how they perceive their role and the role of the team might lead in itself to a conflict, right?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
And I think that's where people shy away from doing work to help them align. And there's always a facilitator that's useful in a situation like this, where you are having a managed conversation, if you like, a proper dialogue that needs to be structured in some way. But I've heard you talk about the need to keep a clean house, you know; the communication, you can compare to that. And then that's almost like saying, oh, well, we're not going to clean up that much because we might get dirty in the process. Well, it's like, well, you know, do you want to clean house or not?
So I think if you take a very practical and a very sort of factual and respectful view on what do we need to be aligned on and how can we go and do that, then you can get some of those conversations out of the way. And what we've shown in our work with other companies is that you can have people align really quite quickly in comparison to a lot of change efforts that go on in organizations today. Because when people see a mental model about how they can look at their world at work in a way that helps them better, and if their view is about, you know, the team comes first, and what are our goals, and what can we do to help ourselves deliver better, if they see a mental model that helps them, they will just switch to that, sort of effortlessly and almost unconsciously and very quickly.
So in this process of this workshop, where you're looking at the data and having a dialogue about it, you're actually changing the way that people see their world at work so that they become more compatible. That's all it is. But I wouldn't say that it's an argument for people not to do the clearing up because they don't want to get dirty.
Ana Adi
Right. So good alignment cannot happen without the potential of conflict arising, but conflict is good, this is what you're saying. I mean, if there was no conflict, we would live in an ideal world.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Well, I wouldn't call that… A good facilitator wouldn't lead a team into conflict; that's not what we want. But people do have to have skills, or a facilitator that can help them with effective challenge, or constructive challenge. So it's very different to have a conversation where somebody says… and they do this a lot in the Netherlands, where I'm based, and this is partly where the inspiration came from, or the way that I kind of look at things these days, is that people can have different views, and it doesn't need to be a threat to their working relationship if they do have different views. It's like, well, oh, okay, well, I see it like this. Or, do you? Well, I had actually taken this point of view and see it more like this. Now, that doesn't have to turn into a conflict or an argument. It's just a recognition of different viewpoints.
Now, when people are facilitated in a way that says, okay, well, what leads you to believe that? What's your assumption underneath that? Often you're uncovering an assumption or a piece of information or knowledge that other people didn't know, and you're actually ending up learning from each other. So the process of alignment is actually about learning from each other, with the same goals in mind. So it's not about going through conflict, it's about managing challenge in a way that is inevitably needed in any complex environment, where misalignment is just part of life.
Ana Adi
Now, you did speak about socializing their thinking, right? The theory that inspired you very much in your work. And when you said that, one of the things I thought of is that, you know, individuals that come into working as a team, they are kind of a cultural product, up to a degree, of their environment and context. And they do come also to work with a certain set of values that will therefore influence their perception of both their worth and what they're doing, and what their profession should be doing. So are you saying that, with focusing on how the team works and how the team performs, these conflicts that might arise from a miscultural alignment, if you want, or a cultural mismatch, can be addressed and even potentially avoided, or if not avoided, at least minimized?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Well, I mean, I think it's well known that it's all very well putting a load of diverse people into a team, but actually managing and harnessing the diversity is something else. And the more diversity you've got, the more diverse views you've got, and the more potential opportunity, let's put it that way, you've got for constructive challenge. And so what you don't want is for people to be coming in and you align them all to be having the same opinion. What you do want is for there to be a robust and lively and positive challenge process that's just ongoing, so that people can bring in their diversity, and that they can be reconciled in a way that everyone can move forward with, so that everybody ends up pulling in the same direction. Even if that means that sometimes they have to maybe accept a view that is not their own, or they can come in with a different way of doing things that other people aren't used to. So managing diversity is, you know, fundamentally, that is, you know, part of the alignment process.
Ana Adi
So now I'm thinking, we're having this conversation amid a pandemic, where we're thinking also of launching the podcast, and most likely we'll still be amid a pandemic. So you've mentioned how important alignment is for teams, and I'm just thinking that we are right now facing and experiencing a slightly different way of working than before, which includes remote and hybrid ways of connecting, including onboarding.
And what you have qualified [inaudible] as employee communication faces quite a new challenge, in the sense of, you know, helping teams within organizations see their common purpose, when what we've been used to as, you know, direct, in-the-office, kind of on the plant and the factory, whatever it is, kind of contact is difficult, if not impossible.
So, considering your experience with alignment and with internal comms and employee communications, how can communicators who work within organizations and face these challenges address them? I mean, one of the other things that we often hear is that internal communicators are, to a degree, facilitators of organizational culture, both in its forming and in its maintenance. So how can they help if they were to embrace this idea of team alignment?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Well, you're absolutely right, there is more challenge around because of remote working. Research done just before the pandemic broke out last year showed that people who are working virtually, this is from Grenny and Maxfield, virtual teammates are two and a half times more likely to perceive mistrust, incompetence and broken commitments than those who are co-located, and people take five to ten times longer to address their concerns. So misalignment is an even bigger issue in the remote working times than it was before, and that's an even bigger reason, if you like, to address it.
And the one thing about identifying and measuring alignment gaps in teams using kind of data, and not pointing fingers at people, is that you can manage that kind of data and you can manage the dialogue around it remotely very well indeed, because it takes the emotion out of the conversation. You're having everybody look at the same data, you can break out people into different rooms and manage the kind of conversations that they're having, and the whiteboards that they're notating their actions or ideas or comments on.
And facilitating better alignment in a remote way, I think, is almost more advantageous than doing it in person, because you can really focus the attention of people in a way that has them talk about things in a much more constructive, practical way, as we've said, rather than in an emotional kind of reaction, where people are tempted to sort of [inaudible] the room or try to escape or turn up late, or whatever they might want to do if they felt apprehensive about having the conversation. So, you know, it's a piece that, we think, you know, just brings alignment more to the fore.
Ana Adi
Five to ten times more likely not to raise this, that is mind-boggling. So remote work, in a sense, makes people a lot more wary of raising up issues with their teammates and colleagues.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Yeah, I mean, if you imagine, you know, being on a Zoom call, and what you really want to do is take someone aside for coffee and say, look, did you hear that, you know, what somebody said? Does this mean this to us? You can't do that on a Zoom call, really. You can do it on a phone call, but you're less likely to have those kind of by-the-way asides, the kind of, you know, that, you know, "I thought that you behaved like this." I mean, that's very difficult to say in a remote way, as opposed to person to person, where you can take somebody aside or give them feedback separately.
Ana Adi
That's what we're talking about, right? So where does that leave us? What would your advice be, considering that we might continue to work virtually for a bit, and, you know, one of the potential outcomes of this pandemic is that we'll have probably more hybrid kind of work, so therefore remote and in the office to various degrees? What would your advice be as we move forward, and particularly to team leads and communicators?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Okay, so let me go a little bit off piste here. Have you ever used a Trello board or worked in an agile kind of team?
Ana Adi
An agile team, yes. Trello, no.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
So Trello is quite interesting, because it takes what would have been lots of long-winded conversations and organizes information in a way that allows people to flip back kind of tasks between each other in order to get something done very asynchronously. So, you know, it turns a kind of query into a comment. You know, a comment field would be a piece of data: you know, shouldn't we consider this? So conversation is kind of being converted into data as we go along.
And I think that's why you used the word [inaudible] at the beginning of this. A lot of the alignment conversations can be brought into a very practical and almost transactional kind of way of talking about things, and agile teams have been doing this for years. So some of the low-impact stuff that people can be doing is, you know, taking some of those agile structures or practices, like daily huddles or after action reviews, and using structures to give conversations much more of a purpose and an effective outcome and a higher level of quality.
Some of that is about, for example, you know, a really good feedback process: this is what I observed, this is what it means to me, this is what I want or wish for. You know, it's a very structured and transactional kind of way of improving the quality of conversations. You know, getting alignment on the map to start with: what is it, why is it important, why is it important to take two minutes out to just explain and reflect on where we're going, where we're about to go, so that everybody can have the opportunity to take questions [inaudible] behaviors, you know, like listening behaviors, effective listening, respect, openness, inclusivity. You know, those are the kind of sort of simple things that people can do to improve alignment just as they go on.
There are much more high-impact interventions, like Mirror Mirror, which is about identifying alignment, measuring alignment and having facilitated discussions. That's really valuable, for example, for new teams or for board-level teams, or for teams that need to make a step change in either the direction they're taking or the performance that they've got going. And those are the kind of interventions that, you know, get deep results. So I suppose there's a lot that people can do in terms of alignment.
Ana Adi
On that note, because we're slowly running out of time, what is the advice that you give yourself, you know, as a communication practitioner and entrepreneur, now that you are so much into alignment, into trying to make people see the purpose of their working together, and then working together better?
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Well, I have always put a lot of emphasis on ensuring that everybody in the team has clarity, or an opportunity to discuss the fundamentals. You know, it doesn't need to take very long. So it is because… I find that it comes naturally and it makes sense to me to do that, and it's my role to do that now, as a leader of a team. You know, that's the advice I give myself, which is: constantly go back, make sure that you're connected with people and that they have an opportunity to, and the tools, the proper tools, like Trello, for example, if you're a virtual team, like other project planning tools and ways of working, so that you really do minimize the clutter and the sort of mess that you can get into if it's not so well organized. So it's about being organized and being human.
Ana Adi
Well, we'll definitely remember that: being organized and being human. I think the human part is the most difficult out of them to achieve. Well, Lindsay, thank you so very much for your time today. Always inspiring. Keep in touch.
Lindsay Uittenbogaard
Thank you very much, Ana. Thanks.
Ana Adi
Alignment of teams within organizations is not a given, and it takes a conscious effort and rational approach to identify and close those gaps. Communicators can definitely support here. It's not about conflict; it's about finding a way that helps teams perform better together.
Our next stop is in the UK, with Jo Osborn, heading RB's, you might have known it as Reckitt Benckiser's, communications efforts worldwide. We'll speak about building an international career and working passionately for projects one believes in.
Women in PR is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com. To learn more about the show and my guests, do check out the show notes. If you liked the show, do share it. If you have comments and suggestions, find me on Twitter or LinkedIn. I am Ana Adi. Thank you for listening.
Women in PR with Ana Adi is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com.