Rochelle Ford's journey and Women in PR interview
In this episode of Women in PR, I speak with Rochelle Ford, Dean of the School of Communications at Elon University, about diversity, equity and inclusion in public relations. We talk about how diversity, inclusion, equity and belonging differ, why the PR profession is not yet diverse, why training without accountability falls short, and how we can teach the next generation of communicators to work in and for a diverse world.
Episode at a glance
Podcast: Women in PR with Ana Adi, Series 2, Episode 15
Guest: Rochelle Ford, Dean of the School of Communications, Elon University (at the time of recording)
Host: Prof. Dr. Ana Adi, Quadriga University of Applied Sciences, Berlin
First released: June 14, 2021 · Length: 59 minutes
Listen to the full episode above or on SoundCloud. Prefer to watch? The episode is also on YouTube, and you can find every episode on my YouTube channel in the Women in PR playlist.
Takeaways (AI-generated with Claude from the episode transcript)
- Diversity is being invited to the party, inclusion is being asked to dance, and equity is being taught the moves
- Diverse voices at the table help teams look at problems differently and find more creative solutions
- Effective communicators understand when gender, age, ethnicity or nationality become salient to how stakeholders see an issue
- PR is not yet diverse, and teams that don't reflect their environment struggle to build relationships with others
- Diversity and inclusion mean sharing power, which can feel counterintuitive and scary to those who hold it
- Diverse talent often leaves because supervisors were never taught to be inclusive people managers
- People move from unawareness to awareness, then allyship, then activism that changes policies and systems
- Training without accountability rarely changes behavior, so tie diversity goals to evaluations, promotions and pay
- Organizations should live their values in every country, even if that means choosing not to operate somewhere
- Teaching diversity takes a foundational course plus reinforcement in every class, from research and writing to design
Transcript
AI transcription disclosure: This transcript was produced automatically with AI speech-recognition software and then edited for readability with the help of an AI assistant (Claude): punctuation, speaker names and the removal of filler words and false starts. It has not been checked word for word against the recording and may contain errors. The audio is the authoritative version.
Ana Adi
This is Women in PR, a podcast about inspiring women that have embraced PR and made it shine, changing it for the better every day. It's about mentors, founders, researchers, role models, and leaders. I am Ana Adi. Women in PR is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com.
Diversity and inclusion have become such a big thing recently, especially after the Black Lives Matter protests in the United States in 2020. Companies around the world, or perhaps their communication teams, felt that it was about time they spoke about the topic. But you see, PR is not diverse. We spoke about this in previous episodes and covered this more extensively in the Women in PR book as well. But generally speaking, there are very non-diverse PR and communications teams in the world, and they're supposed to help organizations navigate internally and externally a world of acceptance and mutual support, when in some cases, they might have no clue whatsoever about how others live and feel. Now, I don't mean to lecture.
Instead, we'll have a conversation about these topics with Rochelle Ford. She's the Dean of the School of Communications at Elon University, a Fulbright specialist, and awarded educator and researcher. And her life's work has diversity in focus.
Oh, and before we go ahead, keep in mind that we might be interrupted by a passing train. Well, home office kind of challenges.
Hello, Rochelle. Thank you for joining me today.
Rochelle Ford
Thank you for having me.
Ana Adi
Now, Rochelle, you are quite known, as we've said in the introduction, as a researcher and academic in the United States, writing very often about issues of diversity and inclusion, not to mention an awarded educator when it comes to public relations. Now, diversity and inclusion has been quite an interesting, highly debated topic in the United States and beyond. So this is kind of what we're going to talk about today.
Rochelle Ford
Excellent. This is what I've been researching. And you're right. It's a global issue. It's not just something in the United States.
Ana Adi
So, but let's clarify terms, right? If we're academics, we'd rather get things straight. What is diversity and how is it different from inclusion? These two terms, particularly in professional environments, seem to be always coming together, but there's somehow an underlying assumption that they're the same.
Rochelle Ford
Right. So I'm going to throw a third term in there as well, because, or fourth. So first, let's start off with diversity. So diversity is all the differences that exist in people. There are some things that we can very easily see. People, the color of their skin. You can see oftentimes gender characteristics or what have you. But then there's other things that we can't really tell, like if they have served in the military before or not, if they're married or single or partnered, what have you. You wouldn't know those things. But diversity is just all the differences that exist in the world.
And then inclusion is a sense of belonging. And a lot of the literature now is using that sense, that word belonging and separating it from inclusion. But in my mind, inclusion is being able to bring your whole self to work, right, or your whole self into an organization. You're not having to hide a piece of your identity so that you belong, right? That's the inclusion part.
But the other part is equity. And we have to recognize that in every society, there are groups of people who don't have access or have not been included in the functions of that society. They've been excluded. So they may not know the systems, the norms, behaviors, et cetera. And so even if they are brought into the organization, there still is a gap simply because there's been a lack of socialization around people who might be running that organization.
So if you think about a party, a lot of us like to join with friends or school functions or something and social gatherings and you want to go to a party and there's music and there's dancing, right? So diversity from an organizational space is everybody is invited to the party. You can be fat, skinny, old, young, black, white, you know, from different countries, what have you. Everyone is invited to this party. That's diversity.
Inclusion is you're invited to dance. We want you to come out on the dance floor and you're going to be able to dance. And you know what? When you dance, we're not going to laugh at you. We're going to accept you for being diverse and different. But as long as you're dancing, you're included. We hope that you feel like you belong.
But the other part is equity. If I've never been invited to the dance and I've never been taught to dance and I get this invitation, I might be very hesitant to dance. I might have fear. So equity would be pulling me aside, show me a couple of moves and say, you know what? Just try it. We promise you, you're not going to be laughed at because that inclusion and belonging piece is there.
But the equity piece would be teaching you to dance. Diversity, inviting you to the dance. Inclusion, saying, hey, we want you to dance. And belonging, when you dance, we're not going to laugh at you. You are part of the group. But, hey, we know you might be a little bit nervous. Let me coach you a little bit. Let me mentor you a little bit on how to dance so that when you get on the dance floor, you feel comfortable and you're set up to succeed.
Ana Adi
Now, I have so many questions going through my mind right now, especially as you use this metaphor of dancing. My first thought was, well, can I choose not to dance? Would still make the place, you know, because maybe that's my true self and I don't want to dance. Would that be?
Rochelle Ford
Go ahead.
Ana Adi
Would that be, you know, would I be spoiling the party? But would the party be as inclusive as before?
Rochelle Ford
So not every party is for everyone. So if we think about it as a company, let's say that I have a public relations agency. I ought to make sure that my hiring practices ensure that there is as many different people coming into my agency. Because I recognize that when we have diverse voices at the table, that we're going to look at problems and opportunities differently and come up with really cool, different solutions and opportunities to really capitalize on those opportunities, right? So we'll address problems differently, we'll problem solve, we'll think more creatively, more innovatively.
So I'm going to open up my doors. I'm going to find different elements of diversity, going to different pools to invite people to come into my organization.
Now, at my organization, you know, we're doing public affairs campaigns. Like that's what our company does. We work with government relations. We work on issues, et cetera. Well, if you don't want to work on issues, right, and you don't want to work in public affairs, then you probably shouldn't accept my invitation to the party because you're not going to be happy and I'm going to be frustrating because everybody here is doing public affairs. And so if you don't like to dance, going back to that analogy, don't accept the invitation to a dance party.
Ana Adi
That's interesting. I mean, I was going to bring it up a bit later. One of the things that we talk very often right now in academia and in public relations scholarship is the emergence of values-based communication and how values-based communication for organizations, no matter the size and type and whatnot, is good. Because it brings, from a communications perspective, higher loyalty and bigger engagement with their stakeholders. So in that sense, if we go back to this argument of values-based communication, then we would be aiming towards diversity, inclusion, and equity.
But the problem, in a sense, that I see with values-based communication is exactly in this metaphor of dancing, that we end up with very different parties, where the cohorts that attend these parties don't talk to one another at all. And we end up with a far more split society or party scene, if you like, communication scene, than we would have had before.
Rochelle Ford
Sure. So let's break apart this analogy, you know, move away from the party, right? So if we talk about this in terms of employees creating a workforce that's going to have, you know, the most optimal returns, bring in additional money, you know, operate at a high efficiency level, you know, have different solutions to really meet the challenges and issues that face my organization, right? Every organization ought to have values, they have a corporate character, and that's how authentic you are in acting out those values activation of that.
So from an employee management, like HR perspective, whether you're a PR department, a communications department within a corporation or nonprofit or government agency, or you're an agency yourself trying to help other types of organizations, a diverse workforce will help you to perform better in the long run. It's often, though, from an employee perspective, a team building perspective, more difficult to learn how to work together, right? Because you don't understand the perspective that your teammate is coming from, because they've been socialized differently.
And that's where that equity part is so critical. Equity would help leaders, team leaders, to be more inclusive in their management style, to lean in, to understand where people are coming from, and then to create systems or programs, activities that will enable people to understand each other, to communicate across difference internally, so they can get to that optimal operations, right? And for team members, they also have to be supported to know how to listen, to how to identify their own biases, and, you know, understand what their own worldview is, and be okay with differing perspectives and learning how to approach things, you know, collectively. But you're absolutely right.
The corporate values would have to state that, you know, we're going to be an inclusive organization, we're going to work towards equity, we're going to accept a whole host of different people from an internal perspective. So that's the internal, you know, HR, talent, you know, perspective, personnel, right?
But if you look at it from the other stakeholder groups outside of your organization, right, different types of publics, and, you know, be it consumers, or, you know, investors, or community, or, you know, whoever, you know, the government, whoever it is that you have to communicate with, even activist groups. That idea of multicultural communication being effective communicator means that you understand those stakeholders, what motivates them, what their communication needs are, you know, what are the things that trigger them to act, to increase their awareness, where they get their information from, what are the things that make them feel connected to an issue that they're going to want to communicate about? Or what are the blockers, the things that inhibit them, right, from thinking about an issue, or, or, so you have to really become experts, and recognize that the elements of diversity may be salient, or important at different times, right? And that's part of that cultural communication piece.
So when you, as a communicator, if you ignore different genders, or you ignore different age cohorts, or if you ignore, you know, people from different nationalities, or ethnicities, or races, what have you, then you're going to be more likely to mess up the communication. Because at times, those elements of diversity, those different diversity characteristics might be salient to them in their decision making. But if you have a worldview, right, that ignores the role that diversity plays, and you act as if you're working with a homogeneous stakeholder group, then you might miss the boat in effective communication. Because at times, issues will trigger age, and your age cohort you belong to might have a bigger role in how you're viewing an issue. It may be your gender, it may be your ethnicity, that triggers how you communicate, how you perceive things.
But your role as an effective communicator is to understand when and what different elements of diversity are salient to the issues in which you're communicating about, So that you can use the appropriate cultural cues, you can use the appropriate language, or visuals, or music, so that it'll be a smoother cross-cultural communication.
Ana Adi
Well, before we go to culture, let's stick a little bit to the world of public relations. And not only public relations, but comms in general. I mean, in Europe, there's debate, right? In the United States, you call what we call here public relations and strategic communications. In other parts in Europe, PR is understood very often as just external comms.
Rochelle Ford
Right.
Ana Adi
And there's some of us in this world who see PR as kind of the encompassing umbrella for comms, that is, organized, persuasive communication, in a sense. But it comes in many forms, and it can be done, in a sense, by anyone.
But let's go back to the public relations profession, because you spoke about the worldview. And I'm just thinking of the public relations profession, and in a sense, the way we teach, and where we come from. And so, is public relations diverse, and inclusive, and equitable as a profession?
Rochelle Ford
No.
Ana Adi
That's the shortest answer I've ever had. So, if it isn't, then we've got a problem. How do we get out of this problem? I mean, I see it, to me, it's a dual-faced problem. One, if you're not diverse as a profession, how can you help organizations? How can you mentor, foster diversity and inclusion when you're not?
Rochelle Ford
Right.
Ana Adi
And then the other is, how do we get there in the sense of, how do we teach? How do we train to ensure that future generations are not going to repeat the mistakes that we might have made, or are not going to be faced with the same hurdles that we might have had?
Rochelle Ford
Right. So, we are not diverse. I don't, you can look across our industries in nearly every country, and you will see a lack of diversity where, or where our internal organization, our public, our communications departments, strategic communications departments, whatever you want to call us, those responsible for communicating and maintaining relationship with external audiences and stakeholders, we don't reflect, oftentimes, the environment in which we're called to operate in.
And that's problematic, because we will lack ability to really build relationships with these other groups of people, because we will be ignoring pieces of our society, because people don't think about the things that they're not exposed to, right? And so, if you have a very monolithic organization, everyone's going to kind of think very similarly, right? And you're not-
Ana Adi
Would you, I'm sorry to interrupt you here, but would you think that the sort of, I call it the mothership thinking, right? This headquarters-focused communication, where everything is trickled down from the top to the rest and slightly adapted is indicative of that sort of thinking.
Rochelle Ford
It is, because people who have power oftentimes don't think about people who don't have power. And why would you want to share power? Right?
Ana Adi
Yeah, why would you want to share it?
Rochelle Ford
Right. But diversity and inclusion means sharing power. And that can be a scary thing. It's counterintuitive that my people group, I'm going to not hire someone who looks like me, who went to the same college as me, that's from a different hometown than me. Why would I hire someone different than me when I want my people group to succeed? Right?
Ana Adi
Well, I think that's, well, okay. So, I see it in both ways. Yes, it can be fun. It can be great. You learn something new. On the other hand, it can be quite a challenging time prone to potential conflict until differences are being understood and eased out.
Rochelle Ford
Exactly. So, why are we not diverse? Okay. So, oftentimes what agency would say, well, yeah, we want everyone to come. Of course, we include everyone. Right?
But then, when you hire someone who is different, exactly what you said happens. They're like, I don't understand you. Why don't you want to hang out with me after work at the bar? I don't understand. Why do you, you know, why do you have to go and pray during the middle of the day? Nobody else does that. We have a meeting in the middle of the day. Like, you can't go and do that. That's not how we operate. So, people, instead of being inclusive, then they start thinking and they treat the person as other and that person wants to leave.
So, in the United States in particular, and I can't speak as much to, you know, other countries around the world, but the United States, oftentimes they will get, agencies will get, and it's primarily public relations, communications, and advertising agencies, and even accounting firms and law firms. Let's just be honest. We're not doing a good job in any sector in the United States, but oftentimes what we'll do is we will find great interns, great entry-level people from a variety of races and genders and socioeconomic levels, et cetera, and then they'll leave after they've been there a few months, a year or two.
Why? Because they don't feel like they belong. They want to do the work. They're capable of doing the work. But what they'll say is, my supervisors didn't include me. They'll say, my, you know, I felt lonely. I felt isolated. I felt passed over. I, you know, I felt like other people were given, you know, assignments that I wasn't given.
And a lot of that has to deal with their supervisors, many supervisors in the comms industry, right? Strategic communications, advertising, PR, marketing. They've never been taught to be good people managers. They've never been taught how to be supportive, how to lean in, how to understand your team, how to be okay that someone is different and is bringing a different perspective or different approach to the work. They've never been taught to be good people. We don't teach that in most undergraduate programs. A lot of MBA and master's programs in communications, they don't teach how to be an effective communications manager of people, how to be an inclusive manager.
So, when these diverse candidates come in, they have a really bad experience. So, what do they do? They leave.
And in the United States, when we were doing research from, you know, the early 90s until today, and you ask surveys of particularly, you know, African American or Black or, you know, our indigenous communities or, you know, the Latinx or Latino Hispanic communities or even Asian American. But if you ask them the size of the organization when you get past that three-year mark or five-year mark, the size of your organization, the size is one. Why? They left the organizations instead of their own shops, and they become freelancers. They become independent consultants because they'd rather not be inside an organization that doesn't want them, that doesn't treat them right.
So, diversity and inclusion, whether it's a communications department within a corporate environment or an agency, needs to start at home. And then it solves all its problems with the outside world.
Ana Adi
But then again.
Rochelle Ford
And then let me reason why I say it helps to, because if you are a woman, it doesn't mean that you can relate to every woman who's in the world. If you are, you know, an African descendant, you're part of the African diaspora, it doesn't mean that you can relate to every other person from the African diaspora. You still have to do research. You still have to find out what the appropriate cues are. But the hope is that if you have diversity within your organization, you're going to approach problems from a variety of views versus having a monolithic department, staff, or team.
Ana Adi
And what is, in your view, the better way to get there, to make sure that not only we're recruiting people that are different from us, but also that they can come to work as their whole selves, as you've said at the beginning of our conversation.
Rochelle Ford
Right. So I think it's a multiple prong approach. I believe that all individuals travel within their own diversity and inclusion journey from some people being totally unaware that this is an issue. They don't recognize why this is a problem. So some people have to begin with the business case of diversity inclusion, the societal ethical case for diversity, equity, inclusion, and to be able to recognize, are we a diverse organization? So it goes from unaware to aware, like, oh, my gosh, yeah, diversity is important. Yes, we do or we don't have diversity. And this is how people actually feel about being included, belonging. And so you're able to do some sort of audit to understand your numbers, as well as the cultural environment, the internal culture. Are we living out our values within the organization, right?
And then you can move from that awareness stage to what you would call, like, allies. In other words, I'm making a commitment for anyone who is different than me that I'm going to walk alongside them in this journey, right? I'm going to help them, you know, I'm going to be sympathetic. I'm going to speak up when I see things or hear things, you know, that are inappropriate. I'm going to, I'm not going to be a passive bystander. I am going to be an ally to those who might be underrepresented or be considered a minority in that situation, right? A minority might be, there's only one woman in your organization, right? Which still sometimes happens. It could be, you know, somebody's religion or something else that makes them a minority at that time. But I'm going to be an ally.
But then the other thing is that members of the organization, you need some people to become advocates and activists, right? That are going to begin to do the systems approach to say, oh my goodness, we have an inequitable hiring practice or we have an inequitable, you know, promotions. Like people don't know what it takes to get promotion. There's no career pathway, you know, that makes it obvious. Or evaluations have something in it that, you know, it becomes a stumbling block to people with diverse identities. So an activist will begin to tear down the systems that hurt your ability to recruit and retain diverse talent and that make it more difficult to have an inclusive organizations. So they approach it from a systems approach. They look at it from policy. They look at it from procedures. And an activist will create that change. And they might institute training and development, you know, programs. They might institute new ways of recruiting and hiring, et cetera.
So it goes from unawareness, like I don't even know why we're even talking about the diversity thing. It doesn't matter to me. I'm not part of it. To recognize that, man, we're all part of this. And look, this is what our numbers are. This is what our culture is. That's the awareness part. To an ally to say, hey, I'm going to take an active role in speaking up, calling out, calling in, and supporting people who are different than me to people who are activists, who are looking at it from a systems approach and making those changes.
Ana Adi
Now, in one of the pieces of research that you've published, which is based on a survey with Arthur Page members on understandings and applications of diversity and inclusion training, cultural, well, not cultural, but rather diversity and inclusion training seem to be one of the categories the most ticked. So that means most of the organizations that you've surveyed indicated that they had these trainings in place.
Rochelle Ford
Right.
Ana Adi
Yet, what I find utterly unsettling is that although there's loads of training in place, respondents to your survey indicated that racial and ethnic minorities still feel like they're the last to know about important changes, as well as they still very few, very much feel overlooked for promotion.
Rochelle Ford
Right.
Ana Adi
So my question here is, is training then really working? And if it's not working, why do we bother and celebrate so much the fact that we have a training in place when clearly, the organization and those who are supposed to be the recipients, you know, the results, the behavioral results of this training, the behavioral results of this training are not benefiting?
Rochelle Ford
Correct. So oftentimes with training is that people go to it, they feel forced to do it. It's done by, you know, the central administration, the headquarters or what have you. The top managers are demanding that it be done, but there was no buy-in to begin with. I have to go to this training. And so there's no behavioral change. There's no attitudinal change. And maybe there's an awareness change, a knowledge change, but sometimes not even that because people feel like they were forced to participate. They might become aware, but they're not trying to be an ally. They're not trying to be an activist.
And the sad thing is, is that even today after George Floyd, a lot of people are like, oh, I'm going to be an ally. I'm going to put up hashtag, you know, Black Lives Matter. But no one became the activist to look at the organization to say, hey, we need to fix this problem. We need to demand, you know, these kind of changes and we're going to hold our supervisors and managers and people accountable. Very few people go from that awareness to real allyship, to real activism, where you change your policies and procedures.
It amazes me. I can literally do the same presentation I did back in the 90s, right, today when I'm talking to senior executives. Because they don't feel like it is their problem. It wasn't until a lot of these top executives were getting boycotted, where their businesses were being, you know, their storefronts and things were being, you know, thrown, you know, bricks through and things during the summer of unrest. That they began to say, oh my gosh, something's going on here. When these executives literally watched a Black man being killed in the street by the police, they go, oh my gosh. Really, there's a problem.
But before that, they weren't thinking about my little actions that I do, as well as my programs, that this is part of corporate character. Like, they would separate the value of diversity and inclusion from the values of the organization. Like, the value of the organization might say respect for everyone, but it really didn't mean respect for everyone. Because if you respect everyone, you're going to lean in and you're going to try to understand the differences that people bring to the table. And you respect that, too. And you understand that. But respect for everyone became more of a slogan than it has to deal with people of different races, different age groups, people of different, you know, different backgrounds. They separated it. It was something that is just for minorities. It didn't have to do with me. It didn't have to do with my corporate character.
But now I'm hoping that there's a level of sincerity there that organizations are saying, oh my goodness. And I see it in the programming now with Page. And I see it in the programming now with PRSA. And I see it in the programming now with a whole host of other, you know, global and national communication organizations, right? That they're saying, yeah, you need to be thinking about these issues, these things, these external things are affecting the internal, as well as your ability to deliver your products and services and to exist. So I'm hoping that that awareness now is literally moving them to changing of systems, policies, procedures to make their organizations more inclusive. If they're more inclusive, they may become more diverse because you fix the equity problem.
Ana Adi
Right. So that's what you're saying, right? That diversity and inclusion is something that you need to solve at home first. So with your employees. And it doesn't really work, the training in itself, unless it's enforced by policies and procedures. So it needs to be a very clean playground, if we call it metaphorically, where people do know the rules and they know how to get from one place to another.
Now, in this article that you wrote for the Institute for PR, reflecting on the survey that you had with Arthur Page members, one of the things that you were saying in order to, that would be necessary to have better diversity and inclusion practices would be to have strong enforcement. And one of the things related to the strong enforcement, one of the suggestions you were making in the paper is to tie diversity and inclusion accomplishments with compensation for both leadership and rank and file employees.
Rochelle Ford
Absolutely. If you don't enforce it, it's not going to get done.
So if you think you're a professor, also educator, so if you tell students to read something, and you never ask them to write a paper, and you don't quiz them, and you give them no homework or assignment, do you know if they ever really read it? Have they ever really understood it? You do assessment of it, right? You assess that they know what you ask them to read, to be trained on, et cetera. But if you simply talk about it, a few of them may be sincere and read it, engage it, and it changes their life, right? Others will be like, you know, she never tests us on anything. And then they stop reading. They stop believing, right?
So it's the same thing with corporations. If you don't measure it, if you don't require, if you don't say, you know, this is so important, it's going to affect your compensation or your ability to get a promotion, then guess what? A lot of people won't think that it's important. And for so long in our industries, this wasn't important enough to tie it to people's evaluations. It wasn't important enough to tie it to people's promotions. It wasn't important enough to tie it to people's compensations.
But I bet you, if you tie it to people's paycheck, guess what? They're going to start thinking about it, and they're going to start moving on it, whether they want to or not. Because what do they want? They want to keep that paycheck and they want a raise.
Ana Adi
Well, but that, again, makes me think of both good examples and bad.
Rochelle Ford
Yes.
Ana Adi
So I could see this being quite a good idea within national borders and within a cultural, generally cultural, homogenous borders. But the moment you work across, you know, in a multicultural environment, and therefore you're crossing national borders as well, that sheer remit of diversity and inclusion might become a problem. Because the way one culture, one cultural profile understands diversity or values diversity, might be very exclusive, if not opposite of what another values, therefore. So how do we move on, in a sense of for saying, yes, multinational corporations or organizations, let's not leave it just into corporations, but organizations need to embrace diversity and inclusion.
Rochelle Ford
Mm-hmm.
Ana Adi
How do we deal with that in a multicultural environment where, as I've said it, you know, it might be that in one part of the world, one value is appreciated, and another is totally condoned.
Rochelle Ford
Right. So if you look at multinational organizations, right, the international, the literature on international communications is like think globally, act locally, right? So you have to adjust to the local norms, et cetera, of that region. But that idea is also a multicultural approach that is a diversity and inclusion approach because you're understanding what it takes to operate in that local community. But if you do have minoritized people, if you, your values of an organization don't generally change from country to country, you maintain your organizational character. That's the goal, right?
Ana Adi
Right.
Rochelle Ford
Is to live out your corporate or your organizational values, no matter what country you're operating in.
Ana Adi
Right.
Rochelle Ford
And so you don't change who you are and your values because you're not operating in another country. It may be lived out in actions and demonstrated differently. So if your corporate value, let's say is respect for all people.
Ana Adi
Right.
Rochelle Ford
When you go to Bangladesh or you go to China or you go to Russia or you go, you know, to France or what have you, or United States, you're still going to respect all people. You're not going to change that.
Ana Adi
It's tough. I'm just thinking of legal frameworks right now. If we're taking very specific cases in some parts of the world, one minority might be outlawed when in another it will be celebrated. So I'm just thinking as an organization, for instance, who goes under, who goes with this idea of respecting people and is very open from its core and believes in diversity and inclusion, welcoming these specific groups that might be outlawed might put a risk both to them and the organization. I said, it sounds terrible. I wouldn't want to be in any of these situations. But I could see how this would be a conundrum for many offices for not doing anything rather than doing something.
Rochelle Ford
Right. So there are tough decisions that companies, organizations have to make. And I think we saw this, let's look at it from a historical perspective. If you go back to, you know, the nineties and before when South Africa was practicing apartheid, there are many organizations that chose specifically no longer to operate in South Africa because they did not, their country policies of apartheid did not align with their corporate values. And they pulled their money and the resources. They took potentially a very big financial hit for doing that, but they stood by their values of their organization because they rejected the apartheid practices.
So if you go back to that earlier analogy, just because someone invites you to go someplace, doesn't mean you have to accept the invitation. Now you might have to sacrifice something because you didn't accept that invitation, but you don't have to go where it is against who you say you are. And companies are due to the same thing. You don't have to be everywhere. Or you go into that environment and you put yourself and you recognize that you're putting yourself and your employees in a risky situation because you're going to maintain your values. And the kind of companies and the individuals who go against who they say they are, they truly did not value those things.
Ana Adi
Well, that's a very, very important point you're making there, right? That we need to move in a sense away from this idea of a perpetual growth mindset and that values to a degree might be limiting, but that's okay.
Rochelle Ford
Right. It is okay to say, I am not going to engage in this scenario. I am not going to sell products or operate because this environment would force me to go against my values.
Ana Adi
Okay. Now, let me ask you something else. A couple of years ago, Starbucks made all the headlines for quite a while around the world because it had shut down all its stores in the United States and subjected, it sounds very unfair as a term, subjected all its employees in a form or another to a racial training day.
Rochelle Ford
Mm-hmm.
Ana Adi
What are your thoughts? You're a communicator, a professor, teaching such things. What are your thoughts about Starbucks's program?
Rochelle Ford
I don't have a problem with Starbucks program, but I haven't studied Starbucks enough to say to what extent it was effective training without accountability of applying what was learned or what was, what was taught to ensure that was learned. And it is then demonstrated in everyday actions is problematic, but if Starbucks followed it up with policies, procedures, reinforcements, to ensure that their training, I think they were doing it on bias, right. And anti-, and trying to stop microaggressions and things. But if it was not followed up with those policies and procedures and reinforcements, right. And accountability, then it may not, we don't know if it had any effect or not.
So it goes back to that same thing with students. Like right now there's a big push that all students have to, you know, in many universities, have to do some sort of diversity course. Of course, it's going to get them to think about diversity, but let's say you take that course freshman year. If no other professor brings in this discussions of diversity, equity inclusion, are the students going to retain that two, three years later? Are they going to retain those lessons and apply them to different scenarios? Did it change their mindset? If there's no reinforcement of ideas and force people to integrate what they learned into their daily practices, it may not be effective.
So the question is, how are you going to follow through? How are you going to measure it? How are you going to reinforce it? How are you going to help people to integrate what they've learned or what they were taught? Because I can't, just because it was taught doesn't mean that it was learned. How are you going to ensure that it was learned? And how do you ensure that it is applied? And that's the question.
Ana Adi
Now you've taken the question out of me. I have to complain here, but you've made a very, very interesting point. And that is, training without accountability serves only to tick the box of raising awareness. And awareness, like many other things, will be forgotten in time.
So my question, but you've answered part of it, is how do we therefore move from, you know, the practitioner problems, the today, to the tomorrow, into how we teach public relations and comms? How do we teach that accountability? And how should we therefore, in your view, design our courses in a way that prepares the future workforce for an environment, a business environment, and not only an organizational environment that appreciates diversity and inclusion, but also provides them with an equitable platform?
Rochelle Ford
Absolutely. So I think it's a both and approach. And so, in other words, you have to introduce it by people who understand this, these concepts of diversity, equity, inclusion, so that they have a frame of reference to draw from. So, and then it takes every single professor while you, and mind you, you might hear a train in the background because I live, my office is right along the train track and there's a train going by.
Ana Adi
Oh, well, we'll hear that now.
Rochelle Ford
So it's almost gone.
So it goes back to unique experts to teach that foundational information about diversity, equity, inclusion, so that you can establish some frame of reference definitions, understanding a common language that can be used. But then in every course that's within their program of study, right, it ought to be naturally infused. So if I'm in a research class, I'm going to be talking about, you know, how to protect human subjects, right? And the questions and things that we ask, because that takes a diversity mindset. We're going to have to talk about framing questions that people will be able to understand, making sure that the type size and things, if you're going to do a written survey, or is there going to be some way to do it orally, recognizing that some people don't have literacy. You know, you have to think through elements of diversity in the research classes, right?
And then if you're having a writing class, you have to make sure that students understand triggering language and understand that words have different meanings among different people groups. If you have a design class, they're going to be thinking about colors and design patterns. You know, some people really read right to left, a lot of people read left to right, you know, it just depends upon the culture, you know, in which you are operating in. So they'll begin to think about how their words and how their images have power and have can be differently interpreted, because then they'll create that multicultural mindset.
If they go into a course that requires them to work on a team, then you're going to have to help them to understand that there are differences in both things that you can see within their teammates, as well as differences that you may not be able to see, but definitely have influenced how those individuals approach work. And it's because there may be different demands on them. And so if they can begin practicing and learning that and reflecting on that team management, right, and you're naming it, and you're saying, this is understanding people's diversity.
Now let's think about equitable ways when you recognize some of your teammates are working a job while they're in school. Ah, now we're thinking about systems. Now we're getting into the mindset that I'm going to have to change policies of the way I approach my team.
So then when I get into the workforce, I'm not going to penalize the female employees or the male employees for taking maternity or paternity leave because I have a mindset that I've got to change my systems to accommodate my team, right? So it has to start with foundational knowledge and then infuse it through everything that they learn.
Ana Adi
So we're going back to this refresh, reinforce, and make sure that as you go along, the policies and procedures make these practices easier to happen and these behaviors easier to be taken up.
Now, before we end, I have just one final question, which is still related to your teaching. You were quoted in another paper talking about your recommendation that public relations knowledge would be used in reverse. In a sense, the paper suggests that your idea would be to research your own students ahead of time. And as you go into the classroom with that sort of knowledge, you'd go with a kind of flexibly around the course that you have taught.
How do we teach flexibility to curricula that needs to be accredited many years beforehand? How do we embed that power struggle in a sense? How do we cope with the potential power struggle, you know, and the students could come in and demand things that we maybe as professors might not agree with?
Rochelle Ford
So I think I'd have to understand examples of what you're speaking of. But what I'm saying is that the outcomes of the course don't change, right? The knowledge that they need to acquire, the skills and competencies they need to demonstrate, we're not flexible on outcomes. But what we are flexible on is how we approach our pedagogy and so that our teaching styles, our methods are appropriate to the learners.
Oftentimes, professors go in and teach the way that they were taught, not recognizing that students don't receive information in the same way that we received information. But we go and do it the same way every year and the students, and particularly as ages, you know, become different gaps between the professor and the student, then there's oftentimes miscommunication and the students don't grow and learn in the way we want.
But if we flip it around and we say, man, my students now, because they are this internet, totally digital, everything in the world is in their hand because of their cell phones and mobile devices, you know, whatever, that I need to, I can only lecture to them for five minutes or less because I'm going to lose their attention. So maybe I need to have more problem solving, maybe I need to have them work in small groups and discuss something and report out, pair and share and all these different techniques, and that the traditional stand up and lecture for an hour and a half doesn't work with this generation, because they're not going to retain the information and be able to apply it because we did not deliver it in a way in which they could consume it.
Ana Adi
But in a sense, the outcomes do change.
Rochelle Ford
The outcomes don't change.
Ana Adi
Well, they do, because public relations, let's debate a little bit. Public relations in the past was taught in a way that posited the public relations practitioners as the servant of the organization. And a lot of the research nowadays presents a different idea. If not various different ideals to the practitioners. So we want them to be well-rounded practitioners. I think that's how we agree on. But how that well-roundedness looks like, it's not the same as you and I had it and maybe experienced it when we started this career.
Rochelle Ford
That's exactly what I'm saying. We're not saying anything different. What I'm saying is that you take the way, me as the professor, I'm responsible for delivering and to delivering content in a way that the students are going to become aware of certain things. They're going to have certain competencies and they may have certain value sets, right? That's the outcomes of my program because accreditation, what have you.
The outcome is the change of the students and their preparedness to operate and function in a modern organization or society doing this function of communication, right? Managing communication, right? Building relationships, you know, between publics and organizations. Being able to see both the, serve the publics while also serving the organization and trying to get that sweet spot of understanding and so that we can have a better society. Okay, all of that's good.
So me as the professor have to take that same approach. I need to know who my stakeholder is, who my audience is, which is the student at this point, right? And how do I get them to behave? How do I get them to be aware? How do I get them to acquire certain knowledge, right? Because I've got a task that I've got to do. So I'm going to deliver, I'm going to communicate in ways to them that's going to resonate to help them become aware and informed.
But at the same time, I recognize that these students have knowledge and information that me, now that I'm like, goodness, you know, 20 plus years older than these students, that they may have ways and modes of thinking that I simply have never thought about. So recognizing that me as the organization, I might need to change because they have something to bring to the table that I've never thought about. So they can challenge me and I can sit and I can go home and I can think about it and I can come back to class with a response. But that takes a lot of self-awareness and reflection. And also a very humble time.
And we old people, as we manage our children and our other lives outside the universities, sometimes we don't want to invest that much time. Let's just be honest. And it's the same thing with the multicultural education. To diversify or what people will say now decolonize your curriculum, guess what that takes? Me learning a whole different way of thinking because I'm required to infuse this stuff that I myself have never thought about.
Ana Adi
And this is why we're in academia. We learn every day, don't we?
Rochelle Ford
Supposedly.
Ana Adi
So whether it's practice or academia, there are a couple of things that you keep as the good recipe to consider for a balanced organization and teaching when it comes to diversity and inclusion. And that is that they're not exclusive, that there is a continuum there. There's a long-term process that they enforce each other. But, however, without enforcing each other and without having equity, we're not going very far.
Rochelle Ford
Yes.
Ana Adi
And reflection and accountability are essential, both in the recognition of what needs to be done as well as in setting up ahead those policies and procedures that would lead to the changing in practice. And whether we do that in the classroom or we do that in a business, organizational, institutional environment, whether it's national or transnational, the foundation is there.
Rochelle Ford
And if you get an A, you get an A, high marks, you get to pass to the next level.
Ana Adi
I am so very glad I passed this test. Rochelle, it's been an utter, utter pleasure. Thank you so very, very much for your time today.
Rochelle Ford
Thank you for having me. I've enjoyed our time together.
Ana Adi
So there you have it. Diversity is about being able to bring your whole self to work. Equity is about the access and the way people are socialized, including in professions. And inclusion is about making sure that everyone is invited. So for PR as a profession to do that, it needs to learn to recognize and experience other world views. And to do that, both individually and professionally, accountability is most needed.
That's it for this week.
Next week, we'll remain within academia and continue the conversation about communication for social justice. We'll do that with Erica Ciszek. She's an assistant professor at the Stan Richards School of Advertising and Public Relations of the University of Texas.
Women in PR is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com. To learn more about the show and my guests, do check out the show notes. If you liked the show, do share it. If you have comments and suggestions, find me on Twitter or LinkedIn. I am Ana Adi. Thank you for listening.
Women in PR with Ana Adi is brought to you by Quadriga University of Applied Sciences in Berlin and professional-podcasts.com.